Longman / Prentice Hall

English



Discovering Arguments: An Introduction to Critical Thinking and Writing with Readings, 2/E
Dean Memering, Professor Emeritus , Central Michigan University
William Palmer, Alma College

ISBN-10: 0131895672
ISBN-13: 9780131895676

Publisher: Prentice Hall
Copyright: 2006
Format: Paper; 624 pp
Published: 12/01/2005

Suggested retail price: $74.00
Buy from myPearsonStore

For Freshman-level writing courses, such as Freshman Composition, English Composition, First-Year Writing, or Expository Writing.

The only argument text that emphasizes style throughout. 

Presenting a holistic view of content and style, this all-in-one argument rhetoric, reader, research guide and handbook helps students analyze and evaluate what they read, argue persuasively, and communicate more clearly than they ever have before.  Students discover, internalize and apply at increasing levels of sophistication the impact of persuasive appeals (logos, pathos and ethos), the principles of critical thinking and the hallmarks of effective style through more than 200 embedded, guided activities directed at their own papers.

 

What are the most important ideas your students should understand about reading and writing arguments?

 

Discovering Arguments presents the classical persuasive appeals throughout the text as the essential argument paradigm, while also exploring the contributions of Stephen Toulmin and Carl Rogers.

 

Chapter 1, Communication and Persuasion: Logos, Pathos, Ethos–sets the tone for the whole text with a discussion of the classical appeals, in the context of writing an opinion essay.

 

~Students find this approach satisfying, and it quickly influences the quality of their thinking and writing.

 

Over 200 guided discovery activities throughout the text-- systematically lead students to understand the most important ideas in argumentation and to apply them immediately to their own writing, reading and thinking.

 

~Gives students unparalleled support as they plan, draft and revise their papers.

 

Toulmin and Rogerian Models–presented as parts of Chapters Two and Three, respectively, and reinforced in activities throughout the book.

 

~Provides students additional powerful tools for reading and writing arguments.

“Thinking with Contraries” as a strategy for argument-- Stimulates thoughtful writing about contradictions and paradoxes, and analyzing contraries in readings.

~Teaches students to use creative thinking skills (such as metaphor, simile, analogy) to complement critical thinking skills (such as analysis, argumentation, and evaluation).

 

How important is good style in your students’ arguments?

 

Unique among argument texts, Discovering Arguments systematically directs students toward stylistic maturity.

Five unique “interchapters” on style and voice— after each of the first five chapters.

~Enables students to learn about language in positive ways, and solve common problems with diction, punctuation, and sentences—so that they can excel at what they say, as well as how well they say it.

~ Each style interchapter contains numerous embedded activities to reinforce the concepts and directs students immediately to extend those concepts to their own drafts.

  

What texts do your students analyze and write about for class?

 

In the second edition, Discovering Arguments presents readings and images on challenging controversies that are relevant and interestingto students.

 

NEW Chapter 5 on visual argument-- examines photographs, advertisements, cartoons and film through the lenses of logos, pathos and ethos.  Includes ten images in full color.

 

NEW completely updated controversial topics-- cheating for success, stem cell research, national service, women in combat, affirmative action, same sex marriage, college sports and organ donation.

Readings by a wide variety of professional writers-- e.g., Ellen Goodman, Richard Selzer, Thomas Sowell, Deborah Tannen, and Martin Luther King Jr.

~Provides students with a large number of interesting articles, poems, essays, and stories on assorted topics. Discussion questions and writing topics follow each section in Chapter 2.

Chapter 6 on thinking critically and arguing about literature–examines poetry, fiction and literary non-fiction.

~Adds flexibility to the course and broadens the genres of texts students can analyze and argue about.

How much of your course focuses on research writing and documentation?

Through an unusually generous section on research, Discovering Arguments enthusiastically supports the research paper assignment and working with sources.

Four chapters devoted to research, sources, documentation and research writing—Based on guidelines of both MLA and APA styles.

~Offers students comprehensive chapters on library use (including virtual libraries), evaluation of evidence—especially Internet sources, documentation, and detailed guidelines for writing reports and persuasive research papers.

 

NEW Emphasis on helping students document their sources. 

 

~Works Cited information provided after the reading selections invites students to analyze and evaluate.  With correct models of Works Cited to follow, students can create Works Cited pages more easily for their own research papers.

 

 

Do your students always have their handbooks with them when they use their argument text?

 

Unique among argument texts, Discovering Arguments provides your students a concise handbook section.

A full section on “Grammar, Mechanics, and Usage” teaches students to recognize and correct basic sentence problems such as fragments, comma splices, agreement, punctuation, and other language skills. 

 

New to This Edition

NEW Engaging, two-color design and larger pages– adds visual appeal and helps the book stay open.

NEW Chapter 5 on visual argument-- examines photographs, advertisements, cartoons and film through the lenses of logos, pathos and ethos, including ten images in full color.

 

NEW completely updated controversial topics-- cheating for success, stem cell research, national service, women in combat, affirmative action, same sex marriage, college sports and organ donation.

  

NEW Emphasis on helping students document their sources.  Works Cited information provided after the reading selections invite students to analyze and evaluate.  With clear, explicit models of Works Cited to follow, students can create Works Cited pages more easily for their own research papers.

 

NEW  “Revision” activities in the style interchapters-- prompting students to apply tools of style immediately to drafts of their writing. 

 

New to This Edition

NEW Engaging, two-color design and larger pages— adds visual appeal and helps the book stay open.

NEW Chapter 5 on visual argument-- examines photographs, advertisements, cartoons and film through the lenses of logos, pathos and ethos, including ten images in full color.

 

NEW completely updated controversial topics-- cheating for success, stem cell research, national service, women in combat, affirmative action, same sex marriage, college sports and organ donation.

  

NEW Emphasis on helping students document their sources.  Works Cited information provided after the reading selections invite students to analyze and evaluate.  With clear, explicit models of Works Cited to follow, students can create Works Cited pages more easily for their own research papers.

 

NEW  “Revision” activities in the style interchapters-- prompting students to apply tools of style immediately to drafts of their writing. 

CHAPTER 1

Communication and Persuasion: Logos, Pathos, Ethos                                                          

      Noticing and Thinking                                                                                                               

      The process of thinking

            The paradigm shift

      Communicating Clearly and Effectively

            Specific evidence

Writing an Opinion Essay

            Finding your subject

      Writing Persuasively

The Persuasive Appeals

            Logos       Pathos        Ethos

      Thesis Statements

            Evaluating your thesis statement

            Guide for thesis statements in persuasive essays

Engaging Your Audience

            Titles      Introductions      Conclusions

      Guide for Evaluating Writing

 

INTERCHAPTER 1

Style and Voice

Diction

            Monosyllabic words       Multisyllabic words

            Pretentious writing

Other Features of Diction

            Specific or general       Concrete or abstract

            Literal or figurative      Avoid cliches        Precise words

      Language and Thought

      Voice

            Features of objective writing

      The writing situation and voice

      Tone

      Analyzing attitude toward readers

      Analyzing attitudes toward subject and self

      Sentence Tools

            Simple sentences      Joining complete thoughts: coordination

            Using semicolons to join complete thoughts

      Solving Two Common Sentence Problems

            Comma splices and run-on sentences

 

CHAPTER 2

Arguments and Controversies

Critical Reading and Writing:

 

Agree, Disagree or Maybe Both

Reading Tools

            Asking questions        Noticing insights        Noticing assumptions      

            Noticing overgeneralizations

      Analyzing and Evaluating Two Essays on a Controversy

            Analysis and evaluation of Mitch Albom’s essay

            Different ways to present other arguments

            Analysis and evaluation of Thomas Sowell’s essay

            Features of outlining         Features of summarizing

      Kinds of Evidence for Arguing: Examples, Reasons,

      Authorities, Statistics

            Using examples          Using reasons

            Using authorities        Using statistics

      Writing an Essay about a Local Issue                     

      Writing a Report to Analyze and Evaluate an Argument

            Guidelines for a report analyzing and evaluating an argument

      Five Essays on Controversial Issues for a Report    

National service        Women in combat         College or pro sports             

            Donating organs          Stem cell research

      Writing an Essay with Sources about a Controversy

Guidelines for writing an essay about a controversy

Organizing an essay about a controversy

Rogerian argument     Advantages of presenting other arguments first       

            Guidelines for organizing an essay about a controversy                   

      Readings on Controversial Issues: Three Case Studies                                                            

            Cheating for Success       Same Sex Marriage       Affirmative Action

 

INTERCHAPTER 2

Voice and Emphasis

      Diction and Repetition

            Repeating words for emphasis      Alliteration

Sentence Tools

            Joining complete and incomplete thoughts: subordination 

            Colons and dashes and voice         Underlining (italics) and voice

            Parentheses and voice

      Fine-tuning Sentences                                

            Sentence fragments: pros and cons          Conciseness

            Omit needless words I             Omit needless words II

 

CHAPTER 3 

Strategies of Argumentation

      Arguing by Induction and Deduction

      Arguing by Illustration

Arguing by Narration and Description

      Arguing by Refutation

      Arguing from Comparison

            Organizing comparison: block and alternate patterns

      Arguing from Contraries

            Using contradictions and paradoxes

            Paradox and tolerance for ambiguity        Either/or thinking

      Arguing from Analogy

            Explaining the mind

      Arguing from Classification

      Arguing from Cause and Effect

      Arguing from Definition

            Digging for roots of words

Definition Essay Using Various Strategies of Argumentation

Analyzing and Evaluating an Essay

Using the Toulmin Strategy to Argue

            Kinds of arguments--kinds of claims       Warrants 

            Guidelines for increasing the credibility of your arguments

      Toulmin and the Psychology of Argument 

            Uncovering hidden values, beliefs, attitudes

      Using the Toulmin Strategy to Analyze and Evaluate an Argument

      Essays to Analyze and Evaluate with the Toulmin Strategy

 

INTERCHAPTER 3

Strategies of Repetition

      Sentence Tools

            Parallelism          Anaphora          Epistrophe 

      The Power of Threes in Sentences

            Using threes in sentences: rising order or not

      Varying Sentence Beginnings: Three Ways

            Using -ing phrases       Using -ed or -en phrases      Using To phrases

 

CHAPTER 4

Problems in Reasoning

      Finding the Facts 

      Implications, Assumptions, and Inferences  

      Fallacies 

      Problems of Insufficient Evidence 

            Overgeneralizing        Card stacking         Ad ignorantium 

            Post hoc ergo propter hoc 

      Problems Based on Irrelevant Information

            Ad Baculum         Ad hominem         Fallacy of opposition 

            Genetic Fallacy        Guilt by association        Ad misericordiam 

            Ad Populum        Bandwagon        Plain folks and snob appeal 

            Ad Verecundiam        Red herring        Weak opponent

            Tu quoque          Oversimplification 

Problems of Ambiguity 

            Amphibole        Begging the question        Equivocation 

            Loaded language          False analogy 

      Problems of Faulty Reasoning 

            False dilemma (either/or thinking)       Non sequitur 

            Rationalization       Reductio ad absurdum       Slippery slope 

      Reading and Writing Activities 

     

INTERCHAPTER 4

Style and Contraries

Sentence Tools

      Antithesis        Antithesis and balanced sentences                  

            Loose and periodic sentences

      Fine Tuning Sentences 

            False starts       Active and passive verbs   

 

CHAPTER 5

Visual Arguments     

Photographs

            News photographs     Guidelines for analyzing and evaluating images

            Staged images       Documentary photographs      

            Fotolog: A new photo phenomenon

            Student essays analyzing and evaluating photographs

            Like a photograph, a painting

      Advertisements

            Commercial ads       Special considerations for analyzing and evaluating ads         

            Ads for social causes      Student essays analyzing and evaluating advertisements

      Cartoons   

            Cartoons and creativity         Creativity and humor

            Serious cartoons         Editorial cartoons

            Special considerations for analyzing and evaluating cartoons

            Student essays analyzing and evaluating cartoons

      Film                                                           

            Writing about a film        Guidelines for writing a film review

            Organizing your film review       Finding and synthesizing sources

            Special considerations for using sources in a film review

            Student film reviews

 

INTERCHAPTER 5

Analyzing Style

      Tools of Style 

      Guidelines for Writing an Essay Analyzing and Evaluating Style       

      Analyzing and Evaluating the Style of a Passage 

      Analyzing and Evaluating the Style of an Essay or a Speech 

      Essays for Analysis and Evaluation

 

CHAPTER 6

Critical Thinking about Poetry, Fiction, and Literary Nonfiction

      Reading and Writing about Poetry 

            The language of poetry        Elements of poetry

            Diction       Imagery         Figures of speech: metaphors,

            similes, and symbols       Tone          Speaker          

            Sound patterns        Structure         Line breaks

      Reading Notebook 

      Writing an Essay about a Poem 

      Guidelines for writing an essay about a poem 

      Student Essay Analyzing and Evaluating a Poem

      Poems to Consider for Writing an Essay 

      Reading and Writing about Fiction 

            Elements of fiction         Plot and conflict        Character

            Point of view        Setting           Moral issues

      Writing an Essay about a Story 

            Guidelines for writing an essay about a story

      Stories to Consider for Writing an Essay 

      Reading and Writing about Literary Nonfiction 

      Writing about a Literary Nonfiction Essay 

 

CHAPTER 7

Library Strategies

      Research Writing Options 

            The informational report         The argument paper

      Modern Research   

      Start in the Library  

            Preliminary reading           Locating your research question

      Strategy One: Finding Background Material 

 

            The general encyclopedias       Specialized encyclopedias

            Critical thinking in a research notebook

      Strategy Two: Looking for Books

            Bibliographies         Online databases and bookstores

            The Library of Congress online      Other online sources

            The public access catalog

      Strategy Three: Look for Articles

            Readers’ Guide to Periodical Literature     Newspaper online archives

            FirstSearch and ProQuest      To use popular sources or not

            Professional, technical, and specialty journals 

      Strategy Four: Look for Reports, Other Specialized Information  

            Government documents, reports        Statistical information  

            Biographical sources online         Book reviews  

      Strategy Five: Use Electronic Sources and Microform Readers

      The Working Bibliography

      Writing a Research Proposal  

            Giving the background research      Describing your project  

            Explaining your methods and procedures  

            Anticipating problems and requirements in your project  

            Discussing the significance of your project 

            Listing your works cited or references  

 

CHAPTER 8

Evaluating Evidence

      Research and the Internet

      Evaluation and the Internet 

            Millions of hits         Print out Internet material  

      What Is a Reliable Site?  

            Evaluating Web sites        Criteria for Web sites

      Who Is the Author?

            Identifying authors        Caution on the Internet  

            Authority         The establishment bias: an exception

            Guidelines for evaluating authors

      Reliable Information: On the Net and Off   

            Context          Timely data         Documentation and credibility   

            Hoaxes, jokes, conspiracies, and frauds   

            Guidelines for reliable information

      Understanding Evidence

            Active reading         Questioning evidence

      Primary and Secondary Evidence  

            A problem solving approach to research       The weight of evidence  

            Magazines and journals        Researchers’ rule         Examining testimony   

            Considering the evidence itself        Defining your terms   

            Occam’s razor: the rule of simplicity       Remaining impartial   

            Remaining objective         Determining relevance         Significance        

            Claim           Persuasion       Judging probability         

            Evaluating statistical data          Problems of questionnaires

      Evaluating the Data: A Test Case

            Summing up the evidence

 

CHAPTER 9

Documentation

      How Much Documentation?  

      Research Problems to Avoid  

            The string of pearls      Underresearched paper   

            Overworking the data       Underdocumentation       Plagiarism  

      Summarizing and Paraphrasing

      Parenthetical References    

      What to Document  

            Direct quotations       Words and ideas from a source  

            Paraphrases and restatements       Discussing the same source

            Source within a source       Content notes  

      What Not to Document  

            Common knowledge  

      In-Text Rules  

            Use author’s name and signal phrase

            Use name and title for more than one work by same author            

            Use shortened titles         Use page numbers  

      Bibliography  

            Authors’ names       Titles          Place of publication  

            Shorten publishers’ names         Copyright date  

      Basic Work Cited Model, Book (MLA) 

      Basic Work Cited Model, Periodical (MLA)  

      Books: MLA Works Cited Models 

            One author       More than one book by same author